1. 'Inner City'
Ryan's statement, which he later said he regretted,
is a perfect example of the way public expressions of racism have
evolved, says López. "You can't publicly say black people don't like to
work, but you can say there's an inner-city culture in which generations
of people don't value work." The goal here, he says, isn't to demonize
minorities—far from it—but to demonize a government that helps the
middle class (and if the people Americans have historically associated
with inner cities have to be used in the process, so be it).
2. 'States' Rights'
Totally innocent and nonracial, right? Not so much. López says we first heard this from Barry Goldwater,
who was running on a very unpopular platform critical of the New Deal,
during the 1964 presidential election. "He makes the critical decision
to use coded racial appeals, trying to take advantage of rising racial
anxiety in the face of the civil rights movement," says López. In other
words, while "states' rights" is a pretty racially neutral issue, you
just have to look at what was happening at the moment to realize that
everyone knew it translated to the right of states to resist federal
mandates to integrate schools and society.
3. 'Forced Busing'
4. 'Cut Taxes'
5. 'Law and Order'
6. 'Welfare' and 'Food Stamps'
7. 'Shariah Law
We first started hearing about this alleged threat to American justice in the wake of the Sept. 11 attacks, says López, when the Bush administration became intent on linking the war in Iraq to hijackers who were from Saudi Arabia. "To get there, you convince America that this threat is internal as well—new brown immigrants who are threatening the heartland," he says. "A prime example is Kansas prohibiting courts from drawing on Shariah law—it's not a threat at all. The point isn't the reality; it's the racial frame. The point is, these brown Muslim people are infiltrating our country, so be afraid, and vote for politicians who will support the right wing."
8. 'Illegal Alien'
3. 'Forced Busing'
López calls this phrase, which, on its face, was racially
neutral, "the Northern analog of states' rights," which "allowed the
North to express fevered opposition to integration without having to
mention race." After all, kids had been bused to school for quite a
while. It was only when the plan took on a racial edge that it became
controversial. Politicians didn't have to say that outright, though—they
simply dropped in the phrase to trigger resentment and gain supporters.
4. 'Cut Taxes'
Dog-whistle politics is partly about demonizing people of color, but
it's also about demonizing government in a way that helps the very rich,
says López. So, when Ronald Regan said "cut taxes," what he was
communicating to the middle class was, "so your taxes won't be wasted on
minorities." A key Reagan operative admitted as much in an interview
quoted in Lopez's book, saying, " 'We want to cut taxes' … is a whole
lot more abstract than, 'Nigger, nigger.' " It continues to be more
abstract, and it continues to work.
5. 'Law and Order'
This phrase, says López, is a way to draw on an image of minorities
as criminals that was used by both Reagan and Clinton. He points to an
inverse relationship in Congress between conversations about civil
rights and criminal law enforcement. "What you see in the 1960s is that
opposition to civil rights becomes 'what we really need is law and
order, to crack down'. " Of course, the latter is less controversial
and, at least on its surface, avoids the issue of race.
6. 'Welfare' and 'Food Stamps'
Welfare, says López, was broadly supported during the New Deal era
when it was understood that people could face hardships in their lives
that sometimes required government assistance, and, in fact, was
purposely limited to white recipients. In this context, it wasn't
heavily stigmatized. Fast-forward to the 1960s, when Lyndon Johnson made
it clear that he wanted it to have a racial-justice component. "Then it
becomes possible for conservatives to start painting welfare as a
transfer of wealth to minorities," says Lopez. Remember those Reagan
speeches about welfare queens? Today, says López, we hear "food stamps" used similarly.
7. 'Shariah Law
We first started hearing about this alleged threat to American justice in the wake of the Sept. 11 attacks, says López, when the Bush administration became intent on linking the war in Iraq to hijackers who were from Saudi Arabia. "To get there, you convince America that this threat is internal as well—new brown immigrants who are threatening the heartland," he says. "A prime example is Kansas prohibiting courts from drawing on Shariah law—it's not a threat at all. The point isn't the reality; it's the racial frame. The point is, these brown Muslim people are infiltrating our country, so be afraid, and vote for politicians who will support the right wing."
8. 'Illegal Alien'
This phrase, says López, is a perfect dog whistle, which
triggers fears about immigrants as criminals, taking advantage of
welfare and disrespecting the American way of life. But somehow the
concerns are always pointed at the Mexican border instead of the one we
share with Canada. "It's racial rhetoric about Latinos that is now being
couched in this seemingly racially neutral language, and harnessed to
support fear to get people to support conservative policies."
No comments:
Post a Comment